RE/MAX Surfside - Cape May New Jersey Location Call Menu

Cape May Real Estate Properties For Sale

Properties Available To Buy in The Beautiful Victorian Town of Cape May

Newest Listings   |   New Construction   |   Foreclosures   |   Recently Sold

Found 23 matching Properties

1 2
18 Pinewood Rd Road, Cape May
18 Pinewood Rd Road - Cape May
MLS #: 600744
Beds: 4      Baths: 3.5
Active      Price: $1,050,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 0 Days Broker Reciprocity
Discover the ultimate shore lifestyle with this exceptional well maintained 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home, perfectly positioned less than one block fro  ... More >
645 Hughes St Street, Cape May
645 Hughes St Street - Cape May
MLS #: 601490
Beds: 4      Baths: 3.5
Active      Price: $2,995,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 0 Days Broker Reciprocity
This iconic showcase home, referred to as the Joseph Hall Cottage, is widely recognized as one of Cape May’s most beautiful and desirable properties  ... More >
909 Corgie Street, Cape May
909 Corgie Street - Cape May
MLS #: 261496
Beds: 3      Baths: 2
ACTIVE      Price: $1,699,999
Type: Single Family
DOM: 6 Days  
Some homes are simply houses. Others carry history in their bones. Built in 1865 and thoughtfully reimagined for modern living, 909 Corgie Street is o  ... More >
1215 Massachusetts Avenue, Cape May
1215 Massachusetts Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 261384
Beds: 4      Baths: 1.5
ACTIVE      Price: $1,675,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 19 Days  
Enjoy comfort, character, and a prime location in this four-bedroom, one full and one half-bath home in Victorian Cape May. Set on a spacious 75' x 12  ... More >
1514 Yacht Avenue, Cape May
1514 Yacht Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 260959
Beds: 5      Baths: 2
ACTIVE      Price: $1,995,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 57 Days  
Unique opportunity and a rare offering of this single family home located on highly desirable Yacht Avenue in Cape May's marina district overlooking t  ... More >
627 Hughes Street, Cape May
627 Hughes Street - Cape May
MLS #: 260998
Beds: 8      Baths: 5
ACTIVE      Price: $2,750,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 59 Days  
Welcome to 627 Hughes Street, a rare opportunity to own a spacious and versatile property in the heart of Cape May’s coveted Historic District. Perf  ... More >
1112 Pittsburgh Avenue, Cape May
1112 Pittsburgh Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 260830
Beds: 2      Baths: 1.5
ACTIVE      Price: $960,000
Type: Twin
DOM: 69 Days  
At 1112 Pittsburgh Avenue, the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a bright, open living space that actually feels like home. The living room  ... More >
225-227 Windsor Avenue, Cape May
225-227 Windsor Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 260785
Beds: 6      Baths: 3
ACTIVE      Price: $2,750,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 73 Days  
Surround yourself with the ambiance of Victorian Charm in Cape May. Welcome to 225-227 Windsor Avenue, a timeless coastal retreat nestled in the heart  ... More >
1323 New Jersey Avenue, Cape May
1323 New Jersey Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 260700
Beds: 7      Baths: 3
ACTIVE      Price: $3,990,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 78 Days  
CAPE MAY STUNNER – Your Dream Colonial Retreat Awaits Just One Block from the Beach! The moment you step onto the welcoming open front porch of 132  ... More >
519 Franklin Street, Cape May
519 Franklin Street - Cape May
MLS #: 260688
Beds: 7      Baths: 5
ACTIVE      Price: $3,499,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 81 Days  
Magnificent 7BR/5BA HISTORIC DISTRICT SHOWPIECE - Fully Renovated to Perfection in the heart of Cape May's Historic District stands a rare 7-bedroom,  ... More >
130 Decatur Street, Cape May
130 Decatur Street - Cape May
MLS #: 260675
Beds: 6      Baths: 3
ACTIVE      Price: $2,695,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 82 Days  
Rare Victorian Gem in the Heart of Historic Cape May – First Time on Market in Decades! Nestled perfectly between the sparkling Atlantic beaches and  ... More >
1105 Pittsburgh Avenue, Cape May
1105 Pittsburgh Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 260437
Beds: 5      Baths: 4.5
ACTIVE      Price: $3,250,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 106 Days  
1105 Pittsburgh Avenue, where modern design meets effortless shore living in one of Cape May’s most exciting new enclaves. This 2023 build features  ... More >
551 Elmira Street, Cape May
551 Elmira Street - Cape May
MLS #: 260053
Beds: 4      Baths: 3
ACTIVE      Price: $3,945,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 151 Days  
Stunning new construction located in downtown Cape May. This thoughtfully designed luxury home features 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and 2 half baths acr  ... More >
824 Stockton Avenue, Cape May
824 Stockton Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 253231
Beds: 6      Baths: 6
ACTIVE      Price: $2,200,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 193 Days  
OPEN HOUSE Saturday June 6th, 2026, 10AM - 1PM Turnkey Opportunity for Historic Cape May Rental Investment for all seasons or a family home. Beach Blo  ... More >
933 Washington Street, Cape May
933 Washington Street - Cape May
MLS #: 252648
Beds: 9      Baths: 5
ACTIVE      Price: $2,860,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 275 Days  
The historic Thomas Webster House, built in 1876, prominently located at the corner of Washington Street and Madison Avenue offers an ideal, elevated  ... More >
1351 Virginia Ave Ave, Cape May
1351 Virginia Ave Ave - Cape May
MLS #: 604121
Beds: 2      Baths: 1.5
Under Contract      Price: $699,999
Type: Single Family
DOM: 0 Days Broker Reciprocity
NEW LOW PRICE...on-island and NO FLOOD INSURANCE required as this beauty is located in an X zone! This charming on-island retreat invites you to slow  ... More >
1105 New York Avenue, Cape May
1105 New York Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 261127
Beds: 4      Baths: 3.5
UC      Price: $3,200,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 6 Days  
Welcome to this classic Cape May home, built in 1914, completely renovated in 2013 for year-round living, and lovingly maintained by the same family f  ... More >
316 Jefferson Street, Cape May
316 Jefferson Street - Cape May
MLS #: 260764
Beds: 4      Baths: 3
UC      Price: $2,349,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 17 Days  
Your Dream Cape May Escape Awaits! Just three short blocks from the pristine beaches of Cape May, this charming and spacious retreat offers the perfec  ... More >
1348 Missouri Avenue, Cape May
1348 Missouri Avenue - Cape May
MLS #: 260994
Beds: 3      Baths: 2
UC      Price: $1,530,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 32 Days  
This is a one-of-a-kind home in Village Green. This outstanding Sandpiper model is a 3BR/2BA single family home, with the addition of a Great room wit  ... More >
526 Elmira Street, Cape May
526 Elmira Street - Cape May
MLS #: 260952
Beds: 3      Baths: 3
UC      Price: $1,750,000
Type: Single Family
DOM: 39 Days  
Welcome to 526 Elmira—a handcrafted seaside retreat where comfort and creativity come together. Just a short stroll to the beach or town, this charm  ... More >
1 2
RE/MAX Surfside
YouTube Facebook Instagram Twitter
Phone 315 Ocean Street, Suite 24, Cape May New Jersey